Judges in Belfast were hearing the final day of evidence and submissions in the case between the Irish News and Goodfellas Restaurant today. The three Appeal Court judges, headed by Lord Chief Justice Kerr, have reserved judgement and will give their ruling in due course.
The Irish News is appealing a decision made in the High Court last year by a jury who found in favour of Mr Convoy, owner of the popular restaurant Goodfellas, and ordered the Irish News to pay damages of £25,000 for libel due to a defamatory critique of the restaurant which was published in the paper.
The Irish News have secured the services of Lord Lester QC ( a Liberal peer, last seen in Belfast representing the pro abortion case for the family planing association, fpa(NI) He is also a supporter of the FPA. He has also previously acted for The Sunday Times and the BBC.) Lester was keen to make the court aware that this judgement would have far reaching implications.
In other words, if the Irish News can’t publish something that will bring a mans business to its knees, then other media outlets might also be affected in that they will have to provide actual “evidence” of assertions made against otherwise innocent people.
Of course all the media have been interested in this case. No doubt they have decided there is an “appetite” for it (amongst themselves at least). And a public interest factor (amongst themselves again).
However, along with the jury I am of the opinion that unfair comment which leads to the loss of a mans livelihood should be accountable.
Lester suggested that if this case was not overturned their would exist a ludicrous situation where theatre critics could not rate a performance for fear of being sued. Au contraire dear Lester, it would be a ludicrous situation if the libel laws became so weak and the press so strong that anything consisting of only “opinion” could be said against a person, and this would be “fair”.
After all what other recourse does a person have against the press than the courts, where hopefully Mr Convoy will get a fair judgement swiftly.
Dear St Joan Of Arc Pray For Us.


This is the last portrait of the Madonna and Child acomplished by Bellini. This subject was his particular favourite as can be seen in the tenderness apparent from the painting.
